I have been reading these threads (Mumtaz & Top City) with interest. I totally agree with Mr. DK. No where has any of these societies spelled out in clear terms the amenities they are going to provide and how they intend catering for all these basic needs. The reports about the area do not give any positive indicators. Even the access road seems in limbo so far as NHA minutes of the conference with potential consultants seems sweet and vague. The interchange which is expected to provide access to both these cities has not been defined and neither any mention of it has been made. CAA decision is yet another factor hanging in the air.
Having said that, of the two Cities I feel Mumtaz City has a definite and very big edge over Top City by virtue of its proximity to the intersection of M1 & M2 and possibly the Interchange on Kashmir Highway!